OPEN SECRETS
2012 awaits. One thing seems certain here at the dawn of the year: whatever drafts of joy and fulfilment we might hope to sup during it are going to have to be home brewed. Any reliance on the usual agencies and the conduits down which their benefices normally flow are likely to be scotched at source. In short, this is shaping up to be a crap year and then some.
But what interests me greatly as the sun rises on the wreckage is just how many of those long-term open secrets will finally be acknowledged as spurious truths, responsible at least in part for our rapid progress towards a self-prepared hell in a self-propelled handcart. Here are three. There are many more.
Let’s start at the top. Capitalism. Is there any serious possibility of a widespread recognition during 2012 that the rottenness at the core was in the seeds from the start? Might intelligent, discerning, observant folk across the world finally accept that capitalism wasn’t an ideology that lost its way? That the reckless vandalism of recent years and its unmediated aftermath of cynical exploitation and continuing injustice are driven by the feral greed that is its fundamental driving force? Could it be that there might be some acceptance on a significant scale that there is no taming the wild beast? Are we ready at last to begin to consider the need for alternative modes of socio-economic organisation?
Education. The black farce of an examination system based on two sequences of two years-worth of force-fed data culminating in two hours of formalised regurgitation has been exposed once again with the recent scandal of subject information being leaked to schools by exam board officials. Year after year teachers and students step onto the floor for the same ungainly, undignified and fundamentally purposeless dance. The same old steps, the same old music, the same old pretence that this awkward, clumsy push-pull peregrination is anything other than a futile performance, devoid of intrinsic benefit and extrinsic purpose. During 2012 could we not, I wonder, accept that this systematised wastage of four crucial years of potential engagement in authentic learning needs fundamental reassessment?
And once the lid has been wrested from that particular Pandora’s box, maybe during 2012 we could invest some time and energy in a careful analysis of the oxymoronic principle of the large school as a crucible of educational endeavour. Another open secret, this: any community within which any members can’t reasonably learn each other’s names has turned into an institution. Its hierarchies will be pyramidal; its processes will be dictatorial; its operations will be dehumanised and mechanistic. No school should exceed 300 students in number and all should have full access to the determining of the predominant culture and day-to-day functioning. While everything’s up in the air and we’re all contemplating void where hitherto we had been perceiving substance, could we not during 2012 address ourselves to this elemental reassessment as well?
The prison system. If any pretence still prevails that the outcome of custodial sentencing within the current system either educates or punishes those imprisoned towards redemption, might we hope that during 2012 the last fumes of it evaporate? Surely we have to accept that prisons are simply places within which we stack high those who have contravened legal constraints beyond fiscal penalty. And can we not accept finally the incontrovertible fact that their deterrent value is minimal. ‘Prisons’, the great anarchist thinker Peter Kropotkin told us, ‘are the universities of crime’. ‘Twas ever thus, ‘twill ever be so. So either we have to shrug it off and build some more, or we have to begin to re-think from basic principles up our entire philosophy and practice of punitive internment. Is there any likelihood during 2012 – a year within which, surely, crime is likely to flourish – of that root and branch reconsideration?
This final paragraph should be the one within which I exhort us all to look ahead with optimism, embracing readily the bracing changes forced upon us by circumstances entirely outside our control down here at the grass-roots. But whilst our immediate crises are not the product of some shared communal malfunction in which somehow all of us share an equality of responsibility, we are at source the authors of our own misfortune. How so? Because our wants, our desires, our ambitions, our vanities, our assumptions have maintained a set of developing priorities and goals through two centuries or more. And through the process of consistently devolving responsibility to sort it all out on our behalf to those to whom we have, largely spuriously, accorded the status of the Great and the Good, we have ensured dereliction and collapse.
So maybe the very best we can hope for in 2012 is a rueful realisation that when the stakes are at the highest and the very best minds, bodies and souls are needed to see us through, we should never, but never, hand power to those who want it most. Indeed, we should always, but always, make room for the reluctant leaders - the humble, the philosophical, the compassionate. Maybe during 2012 we might just begin to turn towards those who, in a world stifling from the blind imperative of limitless growth and gigantism, hold as their enduring priority the welfare of the real person over the abstract notion of The People.
:::
Meanwhile, a new business venture for me in 2012. All welcome! (Menu sent in plain brown envelope).

Recent Comments